Pumpkin Soup

Two blue bowls filled with orange pumpkin soup, with croutons and pieces of crispy fried cheese & pumpkin seeds topping each of them Two bowls of pumpkin soup beside a cookbook which is open at the recipe for "Pumpkin Soup"
Pumpkin Soup with Pecorino Frico
From The Official Stardew Valley Cookbook

Now I am by no means a soup girl, however pumpkins are in season here in Queensland and this recipe from the Stardew Valley cookbook looked perfect for our chilly weather. I used what I would call a butternut squash as they are locally called pumpkins and work very well in a soup either way. I also was unable to find any American apple cider (which as far as i can tell is just raw apple juice?) so I used cloudy apple juice as this seemed to be the best replacement.

Ingredients (a butternup squash, two onions, some bay leaves, cloves of garlic, a bottle of apple cider vinegar, salt and pepper shakers) arranged beside a cookbook which is open at the recipe for "Pumpkin Soup" A close-up shot of some pumpkin soup in a saucepan being scooped up in a ladle

The soup itself turned out hearty and warming, rather ginger-forward (Perhaps a nod to the ‘Ginger Island’ from the game) but definitely rich and satisfying enough to be a main course. I would also highly recommend making the suggested Pecorino Frico as this really brought everything together, tying in the creamy sour cream drizzle and contrasting the smooth and nutty flavour of the soup itself. Mine did not quite crisp up perfectly but I think this was due to my slightly underachieving oven. This recipe could very easily be veganised, I personally love a vegan parmesan when a vegetarian option isn't available. Only other changes required would be vegan butter and omitting the sour cream drizzle.
If you were particularly thrifty and used a traditional ‘halloween’ style pumpkin, you could roast and use the seeds to make the Pecorino Frico.

Two bowls of pumpkin soup showing a swirl of cream and pecorino frico in detail, with a corner of the open cookbook visible in the background Two blue bowls filled with orange pumpkin soup, with croutons and pieces of crispy fried cheese & pumpkin seeds topping each of them

The recipe itself did take several hours but was not all that hands-on, except for me it was due to an over-curious kitten who I do not like to leave alone when the stove is lit. The hardest part was definitely chopping and peeling the pumpkin as this required a fair amount of arm strength and could only be peeled with a knife. I also made the Pecorino Frico and some croutons alongside the soup which added a layer of time management but was ultimately very doable, especially to minimise time with the oven on.

Two slices of butter melting in a saucepan Sliced onoins in a saucepan A saucepan containing brown bubbling liquid, with a bay leaf visible in the liquid. A wooden spoon is resting in it. A baking tray in an oven, lined with baking paper, with diced pieces of pumpkin on it A large saucepan full of orange pumpkin soup

Leftovers stored well in the fridge and I imagine would also freeze well. The Pecorino Frico was kept at room temp and also stored well but croutons do not in my opinion.

Two blue bowls containing orange pumpkin soup. One has a swirl of cream and flakes of crispy fried cheese in it; the other is plain. Beside them are a cup of cream, a large piece of fried cheese & pumpkin seeds, and some croutons

Copyright © 2024 Kitty Goldblatt. All Rights Reserved

Hosted by The Kerwin Network